Please rate this song between 1 star and 5 stars (5 stars being the best). Just move your mouse on the stars above and click as per your rating. Your rating will really help us to improve our website.
Comments for song "Woh Chand Muskaya, Sitare Sharmaye"
ursaheli on Monday, January 26, 2009 Thanks for the beautiful duet by two best playback singers.
A real treat for our ears. Loved it very much:)
bemused321 on Monday, January 26, 2009 You are welcome!
As I noted in the description, Madan Mohan here used music from Brahms' Hungarian Dance Number 2.
Since Brahms also used Beethoven's "Ode to Joy" theme as the basis for the last movement of his 1st symphony (and he acknowledged it by saying "any fool can see it"), perhaps, Madan Mohan can get a pass on this one!
dilij1 on Friday, January 30, 2009 A very melodious duet, thanks, bemused.
madhumatharu70 on Wednesday, February 04, 2009 bahut hi pyara song hai old gane old hi hote the..thanks
nandu1f on Monday, May 04, 2009 What a great melody and enchanting romance. Thanks for bringing out this lost melody, bemused321
getamitg on Saturday, May 16, 2009 an absolutely marvellous gem.. thanks for posting this.. u r doing a great service to music lovers .. keep it up
jasiddiqi on Thursday, June 18, 2009 I just noticed that the first two lines of this melody match exactly with the song from Ek Phool do Mali "yeh pardah uthado zara mukhrda dikha do". it's obvious which one of these came first!
bemused321 on Friday, June 19, 2009 Great observation (listening)!
As you correctly noted, music director Ravi lifted the tune for the 1969 film Ek Phool Do Mali from this Aakhri Dao song of 1958 composed by Madan Mohan, who used the music from Hungarian Dance No. 2 (of 1868) by German composer Johannes Brahms, who based it on the folk songs of Hungarian Gypsies, who are believed to have emigrated westward from India in the 11 th century.
Could we now say that the circle has closed after 700 years?
Madsad1607 on Saturday, July 04, 2009 Bemused, your comment shows deep and wide knowledge. Comments like this make sharing such a pleasure. My thoughts go back to those nomads 900 years back - did their hearts also throb to lilting tunes like this? Just as flowed from them to Brahms to Madan to Ravi it has flowed through centuries - timeless, unbound by person or race, music flows on! The circle will loop again centuries after centuries.
sqhzaidi on Saturday, August 22, 2009 This is one of the greatest duets that I have always loved in my life. I am glad to subscribe and extend a friend's invitation to the channel "bemused321" on account of uploading this melodious song.
aceji on Thursday, August 27, 2009 ALL Music Directors of 50s and 60s were great. They all gave us many immortal songs.Sometimes they used any good tune to create a Hindi film song and that is fine. Ye mera deewana pan hey, sounds like Dekh hame awaaz na dena and Kate nahi katatey ye din ye raat sounds like Dhire chal dhire chal ae bhigi hava etc . It is ok.
apparaovv on Sunday, November 01, 2009 It just like ye raath bhighi bhigi of chori chori
The produser &actor Chandrasekher has not included on the advise of his friends.
Rafidas11 on Monday, November 02, 2009 Wonderful piece with two most malleable voice of Hindifilmmusic. The songs used to be part of the story telling, and the words were apt.
Coming to using tunes - many Hindi music directors used own tunes from previous songs. SJ used their own tunes (antara of yeh raat bheegi bheegi and md. rafi no. taqdeer kahaan le jayegi) (antara of meethi meethi baatonse bachna zara and the duet in Parayadhan Tu pyaar tu preet) and many more tunes that were lifted from Ron Goodwin's ARab
Rmehtacpa on Sunday, November 08, 2009 Arguably ONEOF THE BEST of duets from Indian melodies.
tomandjerry2007 on Wednesday, January 06, 2010 Heard it after sooooooo long..still sounds so sweet.
Thanks4upload.
needi51 on Friday, January 08, 2010 are we discussing history here?
ddheb on Thursday, March 18, 2010 All Manna Dey duets are great, Thanks to youtube and lovers of good music,who care so much to take time and resources to post good music
lovehumanity on Sunday, May 02, 2010 @bemused321 haha.. even if he gets a pass on this song, will u let him go on his lifting of Sajjad sahab's tune of ye hawa ye raat ye chandni from Sangdil to be used in his Tujhe kya sunaoun main dilruba of the same song? I wont honestly :-)
chamogaa on Sunday, May 02, 2010 @bemused321. Crossing boundaries, fusion music, cultural exchange and other similar expressions are more in circulation now, but global borrowing may have started when a tribe for the first time raided another and abducted people from it ,or when different tribes just blended with each other over long treks. You quite rightly remind us of the later,more systematic paths of such diffusion. Thanks,bemused321.
bemused321 on Sunday, May 02, 2010 @lovehumanity Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
Even though I admire Madan Mohan, I find it hard to understand his simply copying Sajjad sahab's tune. There are several other instances when he used western tunes, but this is a rare example of his using another Bollywood composer's tune. Very uncharacteristic indeed.
He does not get a pass on that one ... if the copyrights laws as they exist in the western countries were applied, he could have even gotten a lawsuit ;-(
RealMusicKing on Tuesday, June 22, 2010 Madan's tune: sa ni pa dha ma pa ma ga ma dha dha dha
Sajjad's tune: sa sa re sa ni dha ma ma pa dha pa ma ga
vsv1949 on Monday, July 19, 2010 Brahm's symphony was inspired by wandering Gypsys from Hungary who originated from India 2000 years ago (Punjab and Rajasthan particularly) so a circle is completed after 2000 years, MM being from Punjab.
nandu1f on Saturday, July 24, 2010 Revisit to recharge my heart. Madan Mohan composed some of the best emotive songs for Lata. This is one of those few love songs that capture the best of MM, Manna De and Lata's combined genius. I never saw the movie but all the video songs that I have watched from this movie were well placed and acted out. I wish someone can find and upload the video of this song.
RealMusicKing on Thursday, August 05, 2010 @vsv1949 Wah! Thank you! You said the truth. Surs, Raags all music was discovered in India. While Subcontinent enjoyed lavishly in Mahals and Qilas, Europe dwelled in mud houses till they reached Arab land and the Subcontinent and finally opened their eyes. Thank you again.
arvindpradhan on Wednesday, August 11, 2010 @bemused321 hey guys even as monster group as Beatles lifted a song straight.
Rmehtacpa on Monday, September 20, 2010 @bemused321 Can't say if indeed it was copy of Sajjad, Madan was a class in himself and this number is excellent.
SuraiyaD on Sunday, October 03, 2010 just yesterday i heard a duet sung by mannadey and asha bhosle " sama ye pyar ka bahar ke ye mele" from the movie Baghi Sipahi from Radio Sri Lanka broadcasting ( Radio Ceylon) which i could not find, please help me
Vipin283 on Monday, November 01, 2010 This song was very popular that time and I think I have vedio clips of this son but its in india, ands I m in New York, when I go india sure try to upload this song with original. What a gr8 music by Madanji. Thanks for upload with original sound track. Vipin Batavia New York.
ramesh98 on Sunday, December 12, 2010 @Vipin283 ...Pleaseee upload the video..we all will be very thankful to you..:)..if possible try to ask someone (india) to send it to you or upload it..thankyou
Vipin283 on Monday, December 13, 2010 Thanks Ramesh98 ji, I m planning to visit india in March 1st week and come back in end of april I will sure my all collection of VHS song collection which was recorded in 98 in NY where I worked and recordided so many gen songs. also One of My friend in Rajkot Dr.Yasin Dalal (Heal of Dept. in Journalism Sau.Uni.) May he have so many collectionif I did'nt find in my VHS try to visit him and find some where. Thanks. e-mail ID vvkumarus@yahoo.com
RealMusicKing on Friday, December 17, 2010 @nandu1f Hello. Shankar Jaikishan were assistants to Husnlal & Bhagatram. A fact they never acknowledged during their lives. Shankar Jaikishan had Raj Kapoor on their side and luck. Once Jaikshan died in 1971, RK fired Shankar and their names faded out.
During their golden era, Shankar was good in tuning dance songs while Jaikishan composed most of the romantc songs / duets.
shaharyar06 on Tuesday, February 08, 2011 is any one have full video of this song .it must be picturised but not included for some unknown reasons this is my opinion it may be wrong.
RealMusicKing on Saturday, March 12, 2011 Upon Madan Mohan's demise, actor Manoj Kumar said this "Music is well said to be the speech of angels, but Madan's was superior". Madan Mohan was a rare composer who composed extremely romantic film songs and ghazals. He had knowledge of hindi and urdu languages and poetry. He also had a thorough knowledge of instruments and it refected in his compositions. His was not what one would call "disposable music". In order enjoy, his tunes are to be heard in a relaxed atmosphere.
RealMusicKing on Sunday, March 13, 2011 @bemused321 Hello. Ravi copied quite a bit from Madan Mohan. Madan's "Na Hanso Hum Pe Zamane Ke Hain Thukraye Huwe" from Gateway of India 1957 was copied by Ravi in his "Is Bhari Duniya Mein Koi Bhi Hamara Na Huwa" from Bharosa 1964. That's just one example. He also copied from his master, Hemant Kumar and also from Naushad at various occasions.
Vipin283 on Saturday, March 19, 2011 I m visiting india on 29th march for my 2nd bye pass and after my operation i will try to find this song from VHS casset. I have atleaast 25 songs caswts.every VHS have 4 hrs. sons of all time favourite
MrEdmontonian on Tuesday, March 22, 2011 wo majno ke nana...this is or that one is the copy of each other
MrRajkoemar on Wednesday, March 23, 2011 soooooooooooo beautiful combo lata ji and madan ji. And mannadey also very good.
macmu881 on Saturday, March 26, 2011 Lata made her debut as a playback singer not because of her voice, she came into limelight because her voice was utilized properly while composing songs by the contemporary music directors like Madan Mohan, Naushad, SJ, LP, Sajad Hayder, Roshan, KA etc. Why now Lata is not able to give us a single melodious song? Only because now music directors of panache and talent are not existing.
Djohns Djohns on Thursday, December 15, 2011 very nice singing and mixing sarela ji
latabeatles on Thursday, December 15, 2011 Very nice singing Sarlaji and Nisarji and a very nice dedication to Biplab @bappa366 I like the song very much.
Well performed !
Thumbs UP.
jasbongy on Friday, December 16, 2011 rehmaather has made a comment on Wo Chand Mushkaya Dedicated To Biplab Ji With Best Wishes.:
Wowww! Waht a Superb and Fantastic Duet Bohat Kahoob gaya apne aur Nisar Ji ne.Didi ap ki khubsurat awaaz sunke kano ko sakoon milta hai.Sorry for commenting late There was some problem with my Internet Connection
Didi Jeeti rahiye aur aise hi gate rahiye
God Bless You
Best wishes
Rehma Ather
jasbongy on Friday, December 16, 2011 Thanks Jemal Bhai for your Sincere Best Wishes for Biplab Ji.
Thanks for such sweet & inspiring comment for Nisar Ji's & my singing.
First time i heard this song & just loved it & could not control to sing it .
Bless you. W.R. Sis. sarla.
jasbongy on Friday, December 16, 2011 Thanks Nisar Ji. You have sung very very well. Please check this Video/Song again after one hour to read those beautiful comments.Bless you. W. R. Sarla.
jasbongy on Friday, December 16, 2011 Thanks latabeatles for your kind comment. Yes i like this song a lot & wanted to sing for Biplab Ji .He & Nisar Ji both are excellent singers. With one friend i sang & for other friend we sang.
W.R. Sarla.
jasbongy on Friday, December 16, 2011 bappa366 has made a comment on Wo Chand Mushkaya Dedicated To Biplab Ji With Best Wishes.:
Thanks a lot Sarla ji and Nisar ji for this beautiful song that you dedicated to me...I am really lucky to have friends like you...And what can I say about your singing...You both are marvelous...Thank you once again for your love and warm wishes...
jasbongy on Friday, December 16, 2011 harishkainth has made a comment on Wo Chand Mushkaya Dedicated To Biplab Ji With Best Wishes.:
Waw Superb duet!! Sarla di & Nisar ji u both sing superbly well together. Always like ur duets.. Nice dedication to Biplab ji.. My best wishes to him.. Thums up to di & Nisar ji..
jasbongy on Friday, December 16, 2011 Djohnsify has made a comment on Wo Chand Mushkaya Dedicated To Biplab Ji With Best Wishes.:
very nice sarla ji your rendition best on best
jasbongy on Friday, December 16, 2011 chrismayka has made a comment on Wo Chand Mushkaya Dedicated To Biplab Ji With Best Wishes.:
Dear Sarla,
Thanks for sharing this wonderful edited video with us, your friend Biplab Ji will be very glad with this wonderful dedication to him, wonderful music and great singing, well done, our compliments to you again - B R A V O - THUMBS UP FOR YOU ALL THE TIME !!
Our best wishes to you and your family - God bless you.
Dearest greetings from Chris and Mayka -- The Netherlands -- Western Europe.
jasbongy on Friday, December 16, 2011 KHAN1561 has made a comment on Wo Chand Mushkaya Dedicated To Biplab Ji With Best Wishes.:
didi your blessing always give me new hope ur jawan me nia rang bhar dethi hay allah aap ko ur aap ke perewar ko khush/abad/sahethmand ur apni hifazath me rakhay ameen with all the best khan bhaikavi
jasbongy on Friday, December 16, 2011 ashokkashyap has made a comment on Wo Chand Mushkaya Dedicated To Biplab Ji With Best Wishes.:
Very good song & veru good yr singnig
113 comments related to song Woh Chand Muskaya, Sitare Sharmaye shown on 3 pages.
